Post by dorcas on Oct 19, 2015 23:43:06 GMT
5.2.11.f.c) Recitation: Original or period poetry, stories, comedies..., dramas, et cetera.
Suggestion: Recitation: Existing or original poetry, stories, comedies..., dramas, et cetera.
5.2.11.f.d) Singing: With or without accompaniment. May be a rendition of a period piece or of an original composition written in a medieval style
Suggestion: Singing: With or without accompaniment.
Reasoning for changes: 5.2.3 Already states that “All entries should pertain to Amtgard and/or the medieval or fantasy genres that Amtgard attempts to recreate.”
To attempt to include what you can or cannot sing or recite I believe would either be unnecessarily restrictive or redundant. As long as you follow the medieval or fantasy genre, as in the case with every other category, it is my opinion that the piece is acceptable.
Suggestion: Recitation: Existing or original poetry, stories, comedies..., dramas, et cetera.
5.2.11.f.d) Singing: With or without accompaniment. May be a rendition of a period piece or of an original composition written in a medieval style
Suggestion: Singing: With or without accompaniment.
Reasoning for changes: 5.2.3 Already states that “All entries should pertain to Amtgard and/or the medieval or fantasy genres that Amtgard attempts to recreate.”
To attempt to include what you can or cannot sing or recite I believe would either be unnecessarily restrictive or redundant. As long as you follow the medieval or fantasy genre, as in the case with every other category, it is my opinion that the piece is acceptable.